Cleaning Up After Indoor Pesticide Misuse
How do I clean up pesticides in the home?
If you know which pesticides were used, start by contacting the manufacturer
of
the product(s). The name
of the manufacturer is on the product label. They know whether the product is watery or oily. They know all
of
the product ingredients, and how to break them up. However, they may not know how to clean up the kind of
messes that result from pesticide misuse in homes. For example, it's possible that no one has ever evaluated
how agricultural pesticides interact with carpet, linoleum, or wood.
If you don't know which pesticides were used, don't try any cleanup method, even household cleaners,
without getting some advice from a professional. Some pesticides may react badly with acids or bases, and a
few pesticides even react with water.1 Consider contacting an industrial hygienist or a remediation expert in
your
area. Your local health
department may be able to provide technical advice and
site-specific
evaluations. To learn about a specific pesticide, including its toxicity and persistence, call the National
Pesticide Information Center at 800-858-7378.
There are no standard cleaning rules for removing unwanted pesticide residue from building materials, and
there are many potential dangers to avoid. Consider hiring a professional, especially
if
pesticides were misused
or over-applied in your home.
If a professional applicator over-applied pesticides in your home, call the authorities.
There should never be puddles or piles of dust after a proper pesticide application.
How do I know whether or not cleanup is necessary?
There is no simple set of rules that can determine whether cleanup is necessary, or how much. A professional
could help you identify your main concerns, and evaluate the level of contamination in your home. Pesticides
are
often found in homes at low
levels, even without a history of misapplication.
-
Which product was used? What is the EPA registration number?
-
How exactly was the product diluted?
-
Which rooms were treated?
-
Were any wall voids treated?
-
How much material did you use in total?
How do I know which items and surfaces are contaminated?
Gather as much information as possible about where the pesticide was applied. For example, if it was applied
to
cracks
and crevices, ask the applicator how high up the wall and how much of the floor they treated.
Should I try to get some laboratory testing done myself?
It is very difficult to tell how much pesticide residue is too much in order to protect the health of
residents.
It
depends on the toxicity of the chemical(s) involved, the frequency of contact with contaminated
surfaces,
how
likely the chemical is to volatilize into breathable air, the sensitivity and habits of the residents,
among
other
factors. You might consider consulting with an industrial hygienist who could help you make an informed
decision about whether clean up is necessary.
Before you pursue laboratory analysis of any kind, ask about whether the results can be interpreted to
meet
your needs. Some laboratories offer analytic services without interpretation, leaving people to guess
about
the meaning of test results.
For drinking water, there are published Maximum
Contaminant Levels (MCLs) for many pesticides. That
makes it easy to interpret pesticide detections in drinking water. Was the detected level above or below
the
MCL? For air samples, some risk-based values are available as well.2
For
surface
swipe samples, there are no
such numbers available for easy comparison. For that reason, it may not be useful for the layperson to
rely
on
laboratory testing to determine whether cleaning procedures are needed to protect human health.3
Which materials should be discarded, and which ones can be cleaned?
Porous materials can absorb liquids and potentially dust, taking them deep inside. Non-porous
materials don't
allow liquids or dust to penetrate their surfaces, making them much easier to clean. Table 1
includes common
items, identifying them as porous, semi-porous, or non-porous. It makes a big difference in
determining how
to clean, or whether to discard the item(s).
Table 1. Porosity of common household materials4,5,6,7
Porous |
Semi-porous |
Non-porous |
Carpeting
Clothing
Bedding
Pillows
Mattresses
Upholstered furniture
Fabrics
Leather
Wall Insulation
Ceiling tile
|
Wood
Drywall
Tile grout
Hardwood floor
Linoleum
Concrete
|
Some tiles
Some sealed countertops
Glass
Metal
|
It may not be possible to remove enough of the pesticide residue from porous and semi-porous
items.4,6,8
For
example, one study found that double mopping with detergent, followed by a rinse on a linoleum floor
had
no effect on the level of pesticide residue in a cotton swab test.8
Sometimes,
porous and semi-porous items
are discarded in the process of remediation.
- Do not dry clean contaminated items.
- If clothing was soaked with pesticide, it should be discarded.
- Do not use a professional carpet cleaner without consulting a professional.
- Do not use community laundry machines without consulting a professional. Lingering
pesticide can
put
others at risk.
- Avoid cleaning activities that involve heat, unless directed by an expert. When
chemicals heat
up, they
are more likely to become airborne. A few pesticides may be converted to more toxic
chemicals
when
heated. Some organophosphates are known to do that.9,10
While non-porous items are the easiest to clean, some residue might remain. If items are frequently
handled
by sensitive people like kids (think about toys and bottles) and the elderly (think about medical
equipment,
for example), there is potential for ongoing exposure. Depending on the situation, some items may
need to
be discarded.
Sealants can reduce the spread of some pesticides from contaminated surfaces.6,11
However,
they may not be appropriate for all surfaces or scenarios. A professional could help you make an
informed
decision. If you use a sealant, follow the manufacturer's instructions.
It's preferable to follow the pesticide manufacturer's recommended
strategy
for
cleaning up messes.
They are the only ones who know which sticking agents were used in the product, and possibly, how to
break
them up best.
Where should discarded items and wash-water go?
If you hired a company, they should manage disposal. If not, call your local waste management
agency/company.
Ask whether or not there are regulations that apply to your situation. They will likely ask you
about
the pesticide(s) involved, and about the items you plan to discard. Potential questions include:
- Should contaminated mop-heads and vacuum bags be placed in the trash normally?
- Can you provide a dumpster for contaminated drywall, carpeting, etc.?
Call your local wastewater authority. Ask whether or not there are regulations that apply to your
situation.
Potential questions include:
- How should you handle contaminated mop water?
- Is it appropriate to launder lightly contaminated items?
Bleach may react with some pesticide chemicals. Reactions can result in more toxic chemicals,
unexpected
vapors, or other problems.1,4,5 If you have identified
the
specific product
involved, ask the product
manufacturer
whether bleach or detergent is recommended.
Lacking the
necessary
information, avoid
using bleach. Products that contain sodium hypochlorite are bleach products.
If the pesticide is a dust or leaves dust behind, try to minimize air movement. Turn off
air-handling
systems
and close windows. Dry dust can be cleaned using wet methods to reduce its movement into
the air.
However,
adding moisture can cause chemical reactions.1
Consult a
professional before
wetting pesticide dust.
If the pesticide is a liquid, ventilation will be helpful. As air moves through the
structure to the
outdoors,
chemicals in the air will be carried out.
What about personal protective equipment, like gloves and goggles?
If the specific product can be identified, read the product label and the Safety Data
Sheet (SDS),
provided
by the manufacturer. They will identify the kind of equipment needed to apply or
handle the product.
Those
instructions are based on the manufacturer's unique knowledge of the product. If the
exact product
cannot
be identified, don't guess, and don't rely on a simple internet search.
Dozens of products
can share
the
same
name, but they might have different ingredients and require different equipment
(i.e., gloves,
goggles,
etc.)
for handling.
If the pesticide was applied as a dust, consider using a mask designed for small
particles, rather
than
vapor.
Safety glasses that fit firmly against the skin will prevent dust from irritating
the eyes. Booty
covers may
be
helpful, especially when shoes have laces or fabrics capable of trapping
dust.12,13
If the pesticide was applied as a liquid, consider using a mask designed for organic
vapors and small
particles.13
Protect the skin from contact with liquids used in the cleaning process. Avoid using
gloves made of
any
porous
material, such as leather or fabric.12
Barrier laminate gloves are highly resistant to chemicals in all eight EPA chemical
resistance
categories.12
However, even highly resistant materials will not provide unlimited protection. They
need to
replaced or
cleaned at the end of each day and rinsed during breaks. Other
materials with lower levels of chemical
resistance need to be cleaned or replaced after every 10-60 minutes of contact.
How much pesticide residue has been detected in other homes?
In 2002-03, researchers looked for pesticide residue in vacuum dust and kitchen
floor wipe samples in
Boston
area public housing. Pesticide residues were detected on every kitchen floor and
in all vacuum dust.
In
about
half of the homes, vacuum dust contained five or more pesticides. Similarly, all
of the kitchen
floor swipe
samples contained at least three pesticides. Chlorpyrifos and permethrin were
most commonly detected
in
kitchen floor samples, and the median concentrations found were 0.3 and 6.8
micrograms per squared
meter
(μg/m2), respectively. A microgram is one millionth of a gram. The
maximum concentrations
found
were
19.5
μg/m2 chlorpyrifos and 226.5 μg/m2 permethrin.14
A similar study in 2002 evaluated pesticide residue in kitchen/dining floor wipes
in 20 homes with
children
in the Salinas Valley of California. They also found chlorpyrifos and permethrin
in the majority of
homes
(95%) in addition to diazinon (95%). The median concentration of chlorpyrifos
was 0.046 nanograms
per
centimeter squared (ng/cm2), and the maximum concentration found was 0.20
ng/cm2. A
nanogram is
one
billionth of a gram. For permethrin (trans), the median and maximum
concentrations were 0.23 and 3.6
ng/
cm2, respectively.15
In New York state, a combination of farm, rural, and urban households (41) were
sampled for pesticide
residue
in 2000 and 2001. The largest detection was in the carpet of a farm household
during the summer
months, 33
μg/m2. The maximum concentration found on a smooth floor surface was
13.6
μg/m2 of
malathion.16
Among 90 randomly chosen homes in California, over 97% had detectable pesticide
residues in floor
wipe
samples. The highest values detected were less than 2.0
ng/cm2.17
1 milligram (mg) = 1000 micrograms (μg) = 1,000,000 nanograms (ng)
How much pesticide residue is too much for a healthy home?
It may not be possible to remove all detectable pesticide residues from
household contents. In part,
this is
because modern laboratory methods can detect pesticides at very low
concentrations. Many pyrethroids
(i.e.,
permethrin, bifenthrin) can be detected in swipe samples if they contain
0.001-0.003
ng/cm2.17 One nanogram
is one billionth of a gram, spread over one square centimeter. Just because
it's detectable doesn't
mean it
can
cause harm. The dose makes the poison. To determine the risk, an expert will
consider the toxicity
of the
pesticide and the amount of expected exposure
from living with contaminated items.3
Are some people more sensitive to pesticide exposure than
others?
Young children and
elderly
adults
may be
more
sensitive to the effects of pesticide exposure for physiological
reasons. Pregnant
women, and people
trying to conceive, should also
avoid
unnecessary exposures, in order
to minimize the risk of potential birth defects. There are also
individuals with medical conditions
that put
them
at higher risk when exposed to pesticides. If you think neighbors in the
building may be exposed,
ask them
about any medical conditions or sensitivity, and consider actions that
will help them keep their
exposure(s)
low.
What has been done to clean up pesticides in extreme
situations of misuse?
When a technician misused a concentrated insecticide containing
malathion in Ohio homes in 2010,
authorities
recommended a screening value of 15 μg/100 cm2 on
surfaces. Initially, all porous items
were
removed
and
discarded. Non-porous surfaces were wiped down with warm water and
bleach. After initial cleaning
attempts
were ineffective, experts recommended more cleaning and removal of
baseboards. Further, they
recommended a
polyurethane
sealant on floors where carpeting had already been removed, covered
by a new layer of plywood under
new
flooring.6
In conclusion, it may not be possible to easily determine the risk
level when pesticides have been
misused
in a home. In many cases, it takes a team of professionals to
determine the best strategy and
evaluate its
effectiveness. They have to consider effective methods and the risk
to workers. They often test
residue levels before and after cleanup activities, finding that
some methods don't work as
expected.
Getting
professionals involved, such as industrial hygienists, the pesticide
product manufacturer, and/or
remediation
professionals, can lower the risk of cleanup activities and increase
your chance of success.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this fact sheet is
intended to be helpful as
individuals
make
their
own decisions
about whether and how to clean up materials within the home.
No guarantee of safety or
warranty of
cleaning
effectiveness
is intended or implied. None of the information provided can
supersede applicable
regulations or
pesticide
product
label(s). If decontamination guidance is provided by a
pesticide product manufacturer, it
should be
considered first. No
legal obligations or rights are conferred by this document.
Any mention of trade names or
commercial
products does not
constitute an endorsement by NPIC or by Oregon State
University. The information in this
fact sheet
does
not
necessarily
represent the view of the US Environmental Protection Agency
or that of Oregon State
University.